Skip to content

How we judge and rank

What gets read before the price, what beats what when two documents disagree, where the commission pulls, and the two sentences this site refuses to write.

This page is meant to be checked against the reviews it produced. Each rule says what it excludes as well as what it prefers.

We read listings, and we do not run tests

Every product here is read on Amazon.com from a US address. We record the price, the seller, the rating, the bullets, the details table and the description. No product has been handled by us, and no page says otherwise. The site compares what is published.

What gets on a shelf

A product needs a live Amazon.com listing with an offer when we read it. Products that are out of stock, have no offer, or return a dead page are removed. Imports sold through other Amazon stores at inflated prices were removed in the November 2026 audit.

Every number has a source

Figures come from the listing and are reported as listed, in US units. When the title, a bullet and the table disagree, the review says so and does not pick a winner quietly. Examples on this site: a mower sold as 17 inches and listed at 16.14, a blower with 10 amps in the title and 15 in a bullet, and height ranges with the minimum and maximum swapped.

When a listing gives a figure in a suspect unit, such as a 57-pound dethatcher or a table in the wrong column, we flag it as doubtful. Where nothing is published, the page says "Not published" and does not estimate.

How to read a stated figure

Stated runtime, area, slope and coverage are best cases from the maker. Runtimes assume dry grass and easy settings. Maximum pump flow and maximum head never apply together. A dB figure is only comparable if the method is named, and few listings name it. Our standards pages explain each one.

The score out of 10

Reviews show a score out of 10, built from Amazon buyer ratings. We pull the star average toward 4.3 with a weight equal to 20 ratings, so a product with a handful of 5-star ratings cannot beat one with thousands. We then multiply by 1.7 and add 0.5. The result compares products within a shelf and does not measure performance.

Accessories show no score, and a listing with no ratings shows none either.

How a shelf is ordered

We order products by what they offer a buyer on published figures, price and record. Commission has no part in it. Verdicts name the product, the reason and who should look elsewhere.

What we leave to the label and the manual

Doses, sowing dates, safe slopes and electrical work belong to the label, the manual and local rules. We never tell you that something is safe. We quote what a maker says and say who said it.

Keeping pages current

Prices are dated readings, and the buy box shows the live price. Each page shows the date of its last review, and listings can change under the same ASIN. If you find an error, tell us.

The questions that keep coming in

Do you test the products?

No. We read each listing and report it. No page claims a hands-on test.

How is the score out of 10 worked out?

We take the Amazon average, pull it toward 4.3 in proportion to how few ratings it has, then multiply by 1.7 and add 0.5. A small count therefore moves the score less.

Has a maker ever paid to move up a shelf?

No. There is no listing fee, loaned product or arrangement.

Why does a product have no score?

A listing with no ratings gives us nothing to work from.

Why are Honda and Toro mowers missing?

We only cover products that we could read on Amazon.com with an offer.

Which market do you read?

Amazon.com, from a US address (ZIP 10001).

Last reviewed November 1, 2026